KUNM

Muslim Activist Challenges Fla. Republican's Views

Oct 27, 2011
Originally published on November 3, 2011 6:24 pm

There's no member of the Republican freshman class in Congress more outspoken than Florida Rep. Allen West.

Since he was elected last year, West has become a strong voice on Capitol Hill for fiscal restraint, socially conservative values — and responding to the threat posed by Islamic extremists.

On the topic of Islam, West has been particularly controversial. He calls it not a religion but a "theocratic political ideology" that's a threat to America.

Nezar Hamze, a Muslim activist in South Florida, has devoted himself to challenging West's views. Hamze is the director of the South Florida office of the Council on American-Islamic Relations, or CAIR. It's a civil rights organization headquartered in Washington that has long sought to spread information and dispel myths about Islam.

Hamze says it was with that purpose that he went to one of West's town halls in February. It was captured on video and posted to YouTube by a West supporter.

Hamze brought with him a Quran. In an interview recently, he said he wanted to ask West to explain a statement he'd made at a conference while serving on a panel discussing national security.

"A Marine ... stood up and asked him, 'Why are these people twisting their religion, or perverting their religion, to attack America — as an excuse to attack America?' [West] said that the people that are attacking America are not twisting their religion. They're doing exactly what the Quran is telling them to do," Hamze says.

Hamze went to the town meeting to ask West to defend his views on Islam. He found that West, a former Army lieutenant colonel, is a keen student of military history who doesn't step away from a challenge.

West said "there is talk about killing infidels" in the Quran and reeled off a history of violent conflicts between Muslims and non-Muslims to applause from his supporters.

A Back-And-Forth Argument

Hamze has attended four of West's town meetings and sought — unsuccessfully — to have a private discussion with him. Hamze says he wants to talk to West about the congressman's views on Islam and discuss the larger context of the passages he sometimes quotes from the Quran.

Hamze says there's another important topic he wants to discuss on behalf of South Florida's estimated 100,000 Muslims.

"To make him understand that discrimination and bigotry is real. And his comments are irresponsible and it fuels that bigotry and intolerance," Hamze says.

West declined to comment on Hamze's charges, or on his refusal to meet with the activist. In a letter he sent to Hamze, West says he's not anti-Islam, but he is concerned about what he calls the "radical element of Islam that presents a dangerous threat" to the U.S.

West says meeting with Hamze would be "further legitimizing an organization with questionable associations."

One of West's supporters, Joe Kaufman, an activist running for Congress in an adjoining district, says he believes CAIR has ties to terrorist organizations.

"There is evidence to show that CAIR was raising funds through its website for two charities that were shut down right after 9/11," Kaufman says. "One of those charities, the Holy Land Foundation, was raising millions of dollars for Hamas. And the other charity, the Global Relief Foundation, was raising millions of dollars for al-Qaida."

CAIR officials dismiss Kaufman's charges as "ridiculous," saying their organization has never had anything to do with terrorism. More than a decade ago, those groups were included on a list of charities it referred people to, CAIR says. It stopped doing so when the charities were indicted by federal prosecutors.

Hamze calls the people who are making those claims Islamaphobes. Last month, he sent a letter to West asking him to sever ties with those individuals and groups. West surprised even Hamze with his one-word response: "NUTS!"

Activist Spars With GOP

It's in part to address those and other similar charges that Hamze recently took a new tack — he applied to become a member of the local Republican executive committee.

Hamze is a registered Republican. As a devout Muslim, he says he's a social conservative. One of his first political heroes, he says, was Ronald Reagan. In attempting to join the Broward Republican Executive Committee, he says, he was trying to carry a message.

"There are Muslim Republicans out there," Hamze says. "We do support you, but we want your support as well. We want you guys to, at minimum, not engage in stereotyping and baiting of Muslims."

As with his effort to meet with West, that attempt ended in failure. He was the only candidate out of 11 asking to join the committee who was rejected that night.

The chairman of the Broward Republican Executive Committee, Richard DeNapoli, says it's unusual for candidates to be rejected, but that committee members were well aware of Hamze and his history with West.

"I really don't think this had anything to do with religion," DeNapoli says. "It's just that this was a widely known circumstance where he had made statements against Allen West, and the members reacted to that."

CAIR officials say they have good relations with other Republicans, but that in South Florida at least, the Republican Party and their Tea Party supporters have made Muslims feel unwelcome.

But Hamze is not done trying to change things. He says he is planning now to seek approval from state party leaders to start a Muslim Republican club in Broward County.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:

Since his election to Congress last year, Florida Republican Allen West has been a strong advocate for fiscal restraint and socially conservative values. He's also stirred controversy with his comments about Islam. He calls it not a religion but a theocratic political ideology that poses a threat to America.

NPR's Greg Allen has this report on one Muslim activist in South Florida who's devoted himself to challenging West's views on Islam.

GREG ALLEN, BYLINE: Allen West is a former Army lieutenant colonel and a keen student of military history. He showed some of that expertise last year while he was running for Congress and was part of a panel at a conference held by conservative groups.

In discussing the motivation for terrorist attacks, West launched into a history of conflicts between Muslims and Christians beginning with Charles Martel and the Battle of Tours in 732.

REPRESENTATIVE ALLEN WEST: You want to ask people what happened at Constantinople and why today it's called Istanbul? Because they lost that fight in 1453. You need to get into the Quran. You need to understand their precepts. You need to read the Sura. You need to read the Hadith. And then you can really understand this is not a perversion. They are doing exactly what this book says.

(SOUNDBITE OF APPLAUSE)

ALLEN: Nezar Hamze says it was because of those comments and others that he went to one of Congressman West's town halls shortly after he took office. Hamze is the director of the South Florida office of CAIR, the Council on American-Islamic Relations. The meeting was videotaped and posted to YouTube by a West supporter.

NEZAR HAMZE: Hello, Congressman West.

WEST: How you doing? You're back. Ah, what did you bring here? You brought a book.

ALLEN: Hamze brought with him a Quran and asked West to defend his views on Islam. They quickly began sparring over history.

(SOUNDBITE OF APPLAUSE)

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN: Winning. Keep that up. Preach it. Yeah. Yeah, you're out of here.

ALLEN: Hamze has attended four of Congressman West's town meetings and sought - unsuccessfully - to have a private discussion with him. He says he wants to talk to West about his views on Islam and discuss the larger context of the passages he sometimes quotes from the Quran.

Hamze says, on behalf of South Florida's estimated 100,000 Muslims, there's another important topic he wants to discuss.

HAMZE: To make him understand that on the ground, discrimination and bigotry is real. And his comments are irresponsible and it fuels that bigotry and intolerance.

ALLEN: Congressman West declined to comment on Hamze's charges or on his refusal to meet with him. In a letter he sent to Hamze, West says he's not anti-Islam, but he is concerned about what he calls the radical element of Islam that presents a dangerous threat to the U.S.

Meeting with Hamze, West says, would be, quote, "further legitimizing an organization with questionable associations."

It's in part to address those and other similar charges that Nezar Hamze recently took a new tack. He applied to become a member of the local Republican Executive Committee.

Hamze is a registered Republican. As a devout Muslim, he says he's a social conservative. One of his first political heroes, he says, was Ronald Reagan. In attempting to join the Broward Republican Executive Committee, he says he was trying to carry a message.

HAMZE: There are Muslim Republicans out there, and we do support you, but we want your support as well. We want you guys to, at minimum, not engage in stereotyping and baiting of Muslims.

ALLEN: As with his effort to meet with Congressman West, that attempt ended in failure. He was the only candidate out of 11 asking to join the committee who was rejected that night.

The chairman of the Broward Republican Executive Committee, Richard DeNapoli, says it's unusual for candidates to be rejected, but that committee members were well aware of Hamze and his history with Congressman West.

RICHARD DENAPOLI: I really don't think this had anything to do with religion. It's just that this was a widely known circumstance where he had made statements against Allen West and the members reacted to that.

ALLEN: CAIR officials say they have good relations with other Republicans, but that in South Florida at least, the Republican Party and its Tea Party supporters have made Muslims feel unwelcome.

But Nezar Hamze's not done trying to change things. He says he's planning now to seek approval from state party leaders to start a Muslim Republican club in Broward County.

Greg Allen, NPR news, Miami. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.