KUNM

Judge: Governor Did Not Violate Newspaper's Constitutional Rights

Dec 15, 2017

The Santa Fe Reporter filed a lawsuit against Governor Susana Martinez alleging her staff blacklisted the paper after critical coverage. Four years later, a judge has issued a decision in that case, saying the paper’s free expression rights were not violated but that the Governor’s Office did break the state’s open records law. 

District Court Judge Sarah Singleton ruled that the state’s Constitution isn’t violated when the governor decides not to give certain news organization access to her administration.

Julie Ann Grimm is the Reporter's editor and publisher. "We won’t stop trying to make sure that the public’s business is conducted in public," she said. "Whether you’re a newspaper or whether you’re an advocate for a particular issue, the idea that the government doesn’t have to talk to you is problematic."

The judge did rule that the governor’s staff violated the state’s open records law three times.

The governor’s press secretary Emilee Cantrell said in an email that the Santa Fe Reporter’s claims were overreaching and that the court agreed the Governor’s Office has an adequate process for filling public records requests.

Both sides have until the end of the month to decide whether to appeal.