Environment
2:43 pm
Thu July 11, 2013

Wastewater Wells, Geothermal Power Triggering Earthquakes

Originally published on Thu July 11, 2013 3:55 pm

The continental U.S. experiences small earthquakes every day. But over the past few years, their numbers have been increasing. Geoscientists say the new epidemic of quakes is related to industrial wastewater being pumped into underground storage wells.

Now there's new research that reveals two trigger mechanisms that may be setting off these wastewater quakes — other, larger earthquakes (some as far away as Indonesia), and the activity at geothermal power plants.

Most of these little quakes in the U.S. are too small to feel. They tend to happen in "swarms." Over the past year, geoscientists traced some of these swarms to underground faults near deep wells that are often filled with waste fluid from the oil and gas drilling boom.

Nicholas van der Elst, a geophysicist with Columbia University's Lamont Doherty Earth Observatory, says there are lots of small faults all over the country. The injection of fluids migrates in and around the fault itself, "and kind of pushes outward on the fault walls and makes it easier for the fault to slip," he says.

The wastewater "loads up" these faults with tension until, at some point, they slip and the earth moves.

So what van der Elst wanted to know was: "What prompts that slip?" Sometimes it's just all that water building up. However, he discovered that in three cases in the past decade — in Oklahoma, in Colorado and in Texas — the trigger was yet another earthquake, a really big one, thousands of miles away. In each case, the large earthquakes set up large seismic waves that traveled around the surface of the earth "kind of like ripples," van der Elst says. "You can even see them on seismometers, going around the world multiple times."

Those three big quakes rang the planet like a bell. And when their seismic waves reached underground faults near waste wells in those three states, they nudged the tension in the faults past the brink. Soon, the area near the wells was swarming with mini-quakes.

And some of those swarms eventually culminated in pretty big temblors — in the magnitude-4.0 to -5.0, which is big enough to do some damage.

Van der Elst's findings appear in this week's issue of the journal Science. In the same issue, geoscientist Emily Brodsky at the University of California, Santa Cruz, reports yet another trigger mechanism for mini-quakes: the production of geothermal energy.

The power plant in question, near Southern California's Salton Sea, extracts hot water from beneath Earth's surface and turns it to steam to make electricity, then returns most of it underground. "What we found," Brodsky says, "is that the earthquake rate correlates quite strongly with the extraction of water from the field" underground.

On average, extracting half a billion gallons of water per month resulted in one detectable earthquake every 11 days.

Now, scientists have known that geothermal power plants cycling water from underground can cause small quakes. But Brodsky's research actually matches the amount of water moved to the frequency of the quakes.

These quakes are very small, she notes. But it concerns her that the geothermal plant she studied is near the southern tip of California's San Andreas fault — the source of many of the state's biggest temblors. "We ought to know what's happening on the southernmost terminus of the San Andreas fault," she says. "Of various places in the world to induce earthquakes, this is a particularly sensitive one."

Brodsky says it's unlikely that the geothermal plant could induce a major quake on the fault, but it's theoretically possible. The chance is more than zero, she says, but she doesn't know what the real risk is; that's what she wants to find out next.

The company that owns the plant, Mid-American Energy Holdings, declined to comment on the research.

The U.S. Geological Survey's William Ellsworth has been in the thick of this science. "One of the major questions we're concerned about," he says, "is, 'How large might an induced earthquake be?' We don't have the answer to that, and it's one of the keys to being able to better forecast the seismic hazard going forward." Ellsworth says geologists need more seismic-monitoring stations and more data from waste wells and geothermal plants to figure out the risk.

Copyright 2014 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:

From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Robert Siegel.

AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:

And I'm Audie Cornish. In the continental U.S., there are small earthquakes every day and their numbers are increasing. Geoscientists have concluded that there's a new epidemic of quakes. They say it's related to industrial wastewater being pumped into underground disposal wells. And new research reveals two trigger mechanisms that may be setting off these wastewater quakes. Here's NPR's Christopher Joyce.

CHRISTOPHER JOYCE, BYLINE: Most of these quakes are too small to feel. They tend to happen in swarms. Over the past year, geoscientists tracked down some of these swarms to underground faults near deep wastewater wells. Many of these wells are filled with waste fluid from the oil and gas drilling boom. Nicholas van der Elst is a geophysicist with Columbia University's Lamont Doherty Earth Observatory. He says there are lots of small faults all over the country.

NICHOLAS VAN DER ELST: The injection of fluids goes inside the fault itself and kind of pushes outward on the fault walls and makes it easier for the fault to slip.

JOYCE: The wastewater loads up these faults with tension until, at some point, they slip and the earth moves. So, what van der Elst wanted to know is what triggers that slip. Sometimes it's just all that water building up. But van der Elst discovered that in three cases over the past decade - in Oklahoma, Colorado and Texas - the trigger was another earthquake, a really big one thousands of miles away.

ELST: They set up these big waves that travel around the surface of the earth kind of like ripples. You can even see them on seismometers going around the world multiple times.

JOYCE: Those three big quakes rang the planet like a bell. And when their seismic waves reached underground faults near waste wells in those three states, they nudged them over the brink. Soon, they swarmed with mini-quakes. And some of those swarms eventually culminated with pretty big quakes, in the magnitude four and five range, big enough to do some damage locally. Van der Elst's findings appear in the journal Science. In the same issue, geoscientist Emily Brodsky at the University of California Santa Cruz reports yet another trigger mechanism for mini-quakes: geothermal energy. The power plant in question, near the Salton Sea in California, extracts hot water from underground. It turns it to steam to make electricity and then returns most of that underground.

EMILY BRODSKY: What we found is that the earthquake rate correlates quite strongly with the extraction of water from the field.

JOYCE: On average, extracting half a billion gallons of water per month resulted in one detectable earthquake every 11 days. Now, scientists already knew that geothermal power plants can cause small quakes when they cycle water from underground. But Brodsky's research actually matches the amount of water moved to the frequency of quakes. Brodsky notes that these quakes are very small but adds that the geothermal plant is near the southern tip of California's San Andreas Fault, the source of many of the state's big quakes.

BRODSKY: We ought to know what's happening on the southernmost terminus of the San Andreas Fault. Of various places in the world to induce earthquakes, this is a particularly sensitive one.

JOYCE: Brodsky says it's unlikely that the geothermal plant could induce a major quake on the San Andreas Fault, but it's theoretically possible. The company that owns the plant, Mid-American Energy Holdings, declined to comment on the research. The U.S. Geological Survey's William Ellsworth has been in the thick of all this research.

WILLIAM ELLSWORTH: One of the major questions we're concerned about is how large might an induced earthquake be. We don't have the answer to that and that's really one of the keys to being able to better forecast the seismic hazard going forward.

JOYCE: Ellsworth says to do that, geologists need more seismic monitoring stations and more data from waste wells and geothermal plants. Christopher Joyce, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Related Program