Local News
12:58 pm
Thu November 7, 2013

A History Of Horse-Slaughter In The United States

Horses rounded up in Arizona, set to be sold to "kill-buyers" from slaughterhouses in Mexico.
Credit Rita Daniels

Recently a federal appeals court issued an emergency injunction against the U-S Department of Agriculture that halts all inspections at domestic horse slaughter plants.  

The move effectively freezes the opening of the Roswell Valley Meat Company in Southern New Mexico  as well as a processing plant in Missouri that was set to open its doors during the first week of November. 

Earlier this year the Humane Society and other groups sued the USDA, citing a lack of environmental oversight at the plants. Human Society President Wayne Pacelle says horses are companion animals.

"No one is logically suggesting that we round up the unwanted dogs and cats, set up a slaughter plant in New Mexico or Colorado, and then ship the meat to some far off country where there may be a small taste for dog meat," says Pacelle.  "That would be ludicrous." 

The court will hear briefs in this ongoing legal battle over the next few days. However, even if the plants are allowed to open, Congress is considering a law that would defund USDA inspection of horse slaughterhouses.

Although it is widely believed that humans have been consuming horse meat for eons, the practice in the United States died out centuries ago.

But that doesn't mean that horses haven't been routinely slaughtered in this country for export oversees through 2006.  At that point there were three large Belgian-owned slaughter plants in the US.  Due to a change in legislation, those plants were forced to shutter their doors in 2007.

Over the past few years a handful of facilities across the country have tried to revivify the domestic horse-slaughter practice.  Although slaughterhouses haven't reopened on US soil yet, that doesn't mean that horses haven't been exported for slaughter beyond our borders.  Most of those horses end up at EU regulated plants in Mexico and Canada before the meat is shipped to Europe and Asia where the lean, low cholesterol food is a staple in some supermarkets.

Horses in the US are not raised or medicated during their lifetime with the intent of one day becoming human food, so many of the the animals have often been dosed with medications that are banned by the FDA for use at any time during the lifespan of food animals. 

 

US Horse-Slaughter Legislation Timeline

1998-

*California voters pass legislation banning the slaughter and sale of horse for human consumption.  However the practice continues in other states.

2005- 

*The use of federal funding for inspections of horse slaughter facilities is outlawed, ultimately leading to the closure of horse slaughterhouses in the United States. 

2006- 

*The USDA issues a regulation that allows slaughterhouses to circumvent the horse inspection funding ban by allowing facilities to pay for their own inspections. 

2007-

*A U.S. District Court rules that it is illegal for horse slaughterhouses to pay the USDA for their own horse meat inspections, closing the loophole that had allowed horse slaughter to continue around the federal law.

*Operations at an equine slaughterhouse in Texas and Illinois are shut down for good. 

2011:

*For the first time since 2006 a federal bill is signed into law without the wording that had prohibited horse meat slaughterhouse inspections by the USDA.

*3 horse-slaughter plants, one in New Mexico, one in Iowa and one in Missouri apply for permits to operate on domestic soil.

*A lawsuit filed against the USDA by a coalition of Animal Rights activists challenge the plants opening, citing a lack of environmental oversight.

* The case is currently pending.

2013:

*The Safeguard American Food Exports Act is introduced into Congress. If passed, the Act will declare horse meat unsafe and ban the sale once and for all of horse slaughter as well as horse meat for human consumption in the United States.

*The White House releases a budget proposal for 2014 that would once again prohibit federal funding of horse meat inspections.

 

 

Related Stories: 

Judge Expedites Horse Slaughter Case In New Mexico

Navajo Nation Seeks To Balance Resources With Feral Horse Roundups

Navajo Nation Rounds Up Wild Horses